Skip to Content

Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle: Which is Best for You? (Comparison & Quiz)

newfypoo vs goldendoodle

Are you struggling to decide between a Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle?  With these two great breeds, deciding can be difficult.  These poodle mix breeds are becoming increasingly popular across the world, for obvious reasons! Which should you choose?

The Goldendoodle and Newfypoo are both great pets, but one may be better suited for your lifestyle. While these breeds do have some similarities, they also have a lot of differences which may be the deciding factor for you and your family.

Should You Get a Newfypoo or Goldendoodle? Take the Quiz!

Please keep in mind that this quiz is only intended to be used as a quick guide.  I highly recommend that you read the entire article and do your research to fully understand your choices and make the most informed decision you can!

Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle: Puppy Selection

Availability / Popularity

The most popular doodle breed is the Goldendoodle. Because of that, it should be fairly easy to find a reliable breeder close to you! Newfypoos aren’t as common, and while it may be a little tougher, breeders aren’t impossible to find. You may have to dedicate a little more time to searching for a breeder, or be willing to travel a little farther to find yourself a Newfypoo breeder. 

When you’re selecting a breeder, the most important thing to take into account is that you find a responsible breeder. It can be difficult to avoid the barrage of scams, puppy mills, and backyard breeders. But with some due diligence and patience, you’ll have a new fluffy member of your family soon enough!

Read More: How to Recognize a Responsible Doodle Breeder (and Avoid Puppy Mills!)

While you may find Goldendoodles in rescues or shelters from time to time, Newfypoos are much more hard to come across. Newfypoos may not be labeled as such by rescues, but referred to as just “Poodle Mix” or “Newfoundland Mix.”

Litter Size

Both of these doodles can vary drastically in litter size, usually ranging between 2-10. On average, Goldendoodles may have 1-2 more puppies per litter than Newfypoos.

Price

Newfypoos are in the ballpark of $1,500-$3,000 on average. Goldendoodles are pretty similar in this area. They usually range from $1,000-$2,500. Some breeders will charge higher prices for certain genders, colors, or sizes. This is something to take into consideration.

Goldendoodle vs Newfypoo: Appearance

Size

Goldendoodles can come in five sizes ranging from the tiny, Teacup size of less than 13 pounds or the large, Standard size which weighs up to 85 pounds on average. Newfypoos only come in two sizes—Mini and Standard.

Both of these sizes are significantly larger than the respective Goldendoodle sizes. The “Mini” Newfypooi weighs between 35-65 pounds on average, and the Standard can weigh 65-120 pounds or more! Of course, like all breeds, the size of a puppy is highly dependent on the size of the parents. 

Appearance

Other than the size difference, there are a few differences between the Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle, stemming from their non-Poodle parent, either the Newfoundland or the Golden Retriever (American or English).

Newfypoos tend to have a broader head and body than a Goldendoodle. They also may have webbing between their toes, as their Newfoundland parent is a keen swimmer. Goldendoodles tend to be slimmer throughout as the Golden Retriever tends to be not as broad as a Newfoundland. 

Colors

Coat color is one section where there is a difference between Goldendoodle vs Newfypoo. Goldendoodles can come in a wide variety of colors including apricot, brown, cream, black, white, chocolate, and more!  They can be single colored, bi-colored, or tri-colored.

Goldendoodles will usually have more of a color variation than Newfypoos. Newfypoos generally are either black or brown with the possibility of white being mixed in. They can also be a blue merle color, although that is far more rare.

Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle: Grooming & Maintenance

Coat

Being a mixed breed, the coat of both the Goldendoodle vs Newfypoo can vary. Depending on genetics, their coats can be straight, wavy, or densely curly. This is mainly dependent on their percentage of Poodle vs. their other parent breed. The more Poodle in them, most likely, the curlier their coat will be. 

Related: Short Goldendoodle Haircut Ideas: 30 Before and After Photos!

The genetics and generations of doodles can be difficult to understand, especially for new doodle owners! Here’s a quick crash course on doodle generations…

F1 Goldendoodles have a theoretical 50-50 DNA split between Poodle and the other parent, this means it’s a toss up of which kind of coat they may have. It could be straight, wavy, or curly. Other generations, which contain more Poodle, such as the F1BB (87.5% Poodle, 12.5% Golden Retriever / Newfoundland) are more likely to be curlier.

Grooming Requirements

Golden Retrievers, Newfoundlands, and Poodles all require intense grooming regimens. So it’s no surprise that the mixes of these breeds also require a lot of grooming. Both the Golden Retriever and Newfoundland have a water resistant outer coat and an undercoat. The Poodle obviously has dense, curly hair. Both of these are reasons for regular brushings. 

You run the risk of your dog becoming matted if you don’t brush them regularly. It may seem like it’s no big deal, but that is far from the truth. Matting can be pretty painful for dogs and can lead to sores. Both the Newfypoo and the Goldendoodle should be brushed every other day, if not daily. If you get your dog a short, summer cut, you may be able to go a few more days in between.

Related: Short Goldendoodle Haircut Ideas: 30 Before and After Photos!

My Goldendoodle has an extremely adorable and extremely curly coat. For the longest time he was getting small mats even though I felt like I was just constantly brushing him! I was at my wits end and felt guilty that he was getting matted, so I looked into other brush options.  I eventually decided on the Chris Christensen Big G Slicker Brush.

This brush works wonders! We haven’t had a matting problem at all since we began using it. It’s more expensive than a typical brush, but trust me, this brush pays for itself in saved grooming costs. If you already have a doodle or are considering getting one, this brush is a necessity!

Chris Christensen – Big G Slicker Brush

Shedding & Allergies

Due to their Poodle lineage, both the Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle are allergy friendly, but neither can be classified as hypoallergenic. The only way to guarantee a hypoallergenic doodle is by ensuring both parents, the Poodle and another breed, are hypoallergenic. Since both the Golden Retriever and Newfoundland aren’t hypoallergenic and do shed, it’s impossible to guarantee they’re hypoallergenic.  

If you’re not worried about the hypoallergenic aspect, or just have mild allergies, and just want a dog that sheds less, either of these options would be ideal. The Newfypoo or Goldendoodle would shed less than the purebred Newfoundland or Golden Retriever would.

Read More: Do Newfypoos Shed? The TRUTH About Newfypoo Shedding

Once again, this aspect comes down to your prospective doodle’s generation. The higher percentage of Poodle DNA, the less shedding and the increased likelihood that they will be hypoallergenic. For example, my F1BB Goldendoodle is 87.5% Poodle and 12.5% Golden Retriever. He doesn’t shed at all and doesn’t affect my allergies in the slightest. That being said, this may not be true for all F1BB Goldendoodles. 

If this is a big factor for you, this is the generations in order that are best for allergy sufferers in order from best to worst: F1BB, F2BB, F1B, F2B, F1 / F2 / F3.  This is not a fool proof method, as genetics can be incredibly difficult to predict.

Related: Goldendoodle Generations Explained (F1, F1B, F1BB, F2, F2B, F2BB, F3, Multigen)

Goldendoodle vs Newfypoo: Temperament

Personality

Not only could these breeds win a cuteness contest, but Goldendoodle vs Newfypoo both have some of the best personalities around! Some may say that Newfypoos are one of the sweetest breeds. They’re truly gentle giants who are patient and loving.  Goldendoodles are friendly, affectionate, and loyal. They’ll always be your #1 fan.  However, if you’re looking for a guard dog, these may not be the breeds for you. While the Newfypoo (and some Goldendoodles) can be intimidating in size, generally puppy kisses don’t ward off intruders very well.

These breeds are so full of love, and sometimes, they can become distressed when they’re alone for too long. Both of these breeds are prone to separation anxiety, which is a factor you should take into consideration when choosing a dog.

Activity Level

If you don’t live at least a moderately active lifestyle, you probably shouldn’t be comparing the Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle. Both of these breeds thrive with lots of exercise and should each get at least an hour a day. This could include walks, jogs, fetch, or playing with friends at the dog park. These dogs are likely to love the water, so swimming, fetch, or walks is a great method of exercise.

While exercise is important for both breeds, on average Goldendoodles are slightly more energetic and may require a little more physical activity than Newfypoos. Without enough daily exercise, the Goldendoodle or Newfypoo can become bored and engage in destructive behavior.

Trainability

While both of these breeds are intelligent and are considered easy to train, Goldendoodles have a slight advantage in these two categories. Newfypoos can be stubborn sometimes thanks to their Newfoundland side. Regardless, they’re eager to please and with enough patience, praise, and treats both the Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle can be very well trained.

An often overlooked topic when it comes to training is mental stimulation. Mental stimulation is just as important as physical exercise. Without it, dogs may become restless and destructive. Adequate mental stimulation also means a pooped out pup! If you’re looking for suggestions, this Brain Training program provides fun games for you and your dog to play while helping with the training process!

Good with Kids & Pets?

This category has few differences between the Goldendoodle and Newfypoo. Both are great family dogs and when well socialized become best friends with children and other pets alike.  That being said, Newfypoos have a slight edge in this category due to their calmer demeanor and gentle, less rambunctious nature.

Newfypoo vs Goldendoodle: Health & Wellness

Life Span

In the debate between a Goldendoodle vs Newfypoo, this is one area where the Goldendoodle has an advantage.  The average Goldendoodle lives for between 10-15 years, while the Newfypoo has a shorter expected lifespan between 8-12 years. 

Potential Illnesses

Mixed breeds often are associated with better health due to their mixed gene pool. This means they’re less likely to get hereditary diseases that purebreds do. Despite their decreased chance of inheriting conditions, they are susceptible to diseases that run in both parental lines. 

Common health problems in Newfypoos include cataracts, hip dysplasia, subaortic stenosis, bloat, and sebaceous adenitis. Another thing to keep in mind with this giant breed is that they’re prone to suffering from joint issues simply due to their size. One way to combat this is to limit activities like jumping which can be especially hard on the joints. 

Some health issues that Goldendoodles may deal with can include atropic dermatitis, infections of the ears, patellar luxation, hip dysplasia, Von Willebrand disease, and epilepsy. 

All dogs have the chance to suffer from a health problem or accident.  That’s why I recommend all new dog owners purchase pet insurance which can cover up to 90% of veterinary bills for accidents and injuries. As one example, a patellar luxation can cost $1,500-$3,000 per knee to repair! With pet insurance, cost never stands between you and providing your dog with the care they need.

I stand behind pet insurance because I personally use it. I use Healthy Paws pet insurance and can’t imagine life without it. The most important thing it gives me is peace of mind that my dog, my best friend, will always have the medical care he needs.

Should you get a Goldendoodle or Newfypoo? The conclusion…

  • If you love big dogs, the Newfypoo might be the better option because it tends to be bigger. On the other hand, if you are looking for a smaller dog, the Toy or Mini Goldendoodle may be right for you.
  • Goldendoodles tend to live a few years longer than Newfypoos. 
  • Newfypoo breeders may be a little harder to find as they’re not as popular as Goldendoodles. Litters also tend to be slightly smaller.
  • While both are great with kids and pets, Newfypoos tend to be slightly more gentle which can be great for young children.

Compare the Goldendoodle